A skeleton dances in an orange frame, one bony arm thrown up towards the corner, the other bent at the hip. Around its feet sit grinning jack-o'-lanterns and a pile of skulls, under bare branches and a dark, speckled sky. The colours are faded and the edges smeared, like a picture taped off a television in the 1970s.
The picture appears for a few seconds in Late Night with the Devil, an Australian horror film released in US cinemas on 22 March 2024. In the days before that release, screenshots of it and of similar cards spread on Letterboxd and X with one accusation: these were made by SI (AI). Unlike most of the images in our fact-check series, nobody claimed this one showed a real event. The question was simpler: did a film praised for its handmade 1970s look use an image generator? This fact-check follows what viewers saw, what the filmmakers confirmed, and what an SI check of the still returns.
Claim: Late Night with the Devil uses SI-generated images.
Verdict: true, for three still images. The writer-directors, brothers Cameron and Colin Cairnes, told Variety on 21 March 2024 that they "experimented with AI for three still images" which they "edited further" and which "appear as very brief interstitials in the film". The rest of the film's graphics and effects were made by their team. A copy of one of the stills scored 99% likely SI in our detector.
What the film is, and where the images appear
Late Night with the Devil is presented as the recovered footage of a fictional talk show, Night Owls with Jack Delroy, on Halloween night 1977. David Dastmalchian plays the host, who stages an occult special to save his ratings and keeps the cameras rolling as it goes wrong. The film was shot in Melbourne in mid-2022 and premiered at the South by Southwest festival (SXSW) in Austin on 10 March 2023. IFC Films and Shudder released it in the United States a year later, on 22 March 2024, with streaming on Shudder from 19 April.
Because the story is told as a broadcast, the film regularly cuts away from the studio. As The Daily Beast described it, the show occasionally cuts to an unplanned "commercial", with Halloween-themed "eyecatches" on screen. PetaPixel listed among the disputed images an illustration of a skeleton dancing in a pumpkin patch and the occasional "We'll be right back" message. The Letterboxd Journal called them interstitial "we'll be right back" images. They are on screen for a few seconds at a time.
That detail matters for what comes next. Nobody was misled about a news event here. The dispute was about authorship: whether pictures that look like period artwork were drawn by a person or produced by software.
How viewers spotted them
According to Variety, the criticism started with a Letterboxd review posted on 19 March 2024 by a user called "based gizmo", who wrote that because of the use of SI, "I can't enjoy the amazing performances and clever ending." More low ratings followed on Letterboxd, and the discussion moved to X. The Daily Beast reported that social media users had first flagged the graphics in teasers for the film, and that one Letterboxd user accused the platform of "shadow-banning" their review. On 20 March, an X user posted images captioned "for anyone doubting late night with the devil uses AI", which PetaPixel later embedded.
What gave the images away? The Daily Beast pointed to the most notable example, the skeleton, "whose hand appears warped", which it called a telltale sign of image generation software. Hands are a classic weak point of generators: fingers merge, multiply or bend the wrong way. Look again at the dancing skeleton and the raised hand is a tangle of curled finger bones that does not quite resolve into a hand, while the rest of the skeleton is clean and confident.
The A.V. Club, which called them "those viral AI images", made the broader point that it was still "relatively easy" in 2024 to tell when an image is generated. That was true of these cards, but it is worth being careful with the lesson. A warped hand is a clue, not a proof. Illustrators distort anatomy on purpose all the time, and a skeleton drawn in a loose, cartoon style is exactly the kind of picture where the line between stylisation and error is hard to draw. Our test of SI art against real art shows how much harder illustrations are than photos, for people and detectors alike.
What the directors and the star said
On 21 March 2024, the day before release, Cameron and Colin Cairnes gave a short statement to Variety and The Daily Beast:
"In conjunction with our amazing graphics and production design team, all of whom worked tirelessly to give this film the 70s aesthetic we had always imagined, we experimented with AI for three still images which we edited further and ultimately appear as very brief interstitials in the film."
So the accusation was confirmed, and its scope was set: three stills, reworked by hand, among a film's worth of graphics made by people. The statement did not name the generator they used, and we have not found a source that does.
Dastmalchian addressed it the same day in a video interview with journalist Kevin McCarthy, quoted by IndieWire. He said the film had been made "a couple of years ago", and that "the only thing that makes me sad is that we had such an awesome graphics design team and all the artists were working on making this film so perfect, so it makes me sad that that's a story that's getting attention. But I get it." He described the moment as "brand new stuff", along the lines of "Oh look, this thing generated an image and now our artists are doing it".
The longest account came from the brothers themselves, in a Letterboxd Journal interview published on 15 April 2024 under a headline quoting their accidental "A.I. apology tour". Colin Cairnes explained that their producers were also their visual effects artists and graphic designers, and that one producer, Adam White, did 300 visual effects on his own. He said they had paid illustrator Lukas Ketner for a shot that is in the film "for three seconds", and that without the SI experiment "we would have just ended up repeating some other graphics that our team had done anyway."
He was blunt about the result, too: "I don't know if we'd do it again, not for necessarily ethical reasons", he said, before adding that it was "not worth the effort" and that "to get those three pictures, I don't know how many iterations there were." Asked whether the images would be replaced for the streaming or physical release, he said that if "someone higher up" thought so, they would have that conversation, but that he did not think they should be "caving into" outrage he partly blamed on "exaggerated claims".
Why three images caused a storm
On screen, the stills add up to seconds. The reaction was out of proportion to that, and the reason is timing. Between the film's SXSW premiere and its release, Hollywood went through the 2023 writers' and actors' strikes, in which SI was a central issue. Variety summed up the outcome: the new Writers Guild of America (WGA) contract says "AI-generated material can't be used to undermine a writer's credit or separated rights", while the SAG-AFTRA deal set consent and compensation rules for using SI to replicate actors' likenesses. As The Daily Beast noted, neither contract covers art and illustration.
That gap is where graphic artists saw a threat. PetaPixel quoted film journalist Matt Bellissimo: "The big deal is that it always starts with small images and TV show intros to cut corners and undercut artists." The A.V. Club quoted one disappointed viewer: "This could have been a dream job for an artist like me."
Others pushed back on calls for a boycott. IndieWire quoted film journalist Rendy Jones, who wrote that there was "no excuse" since the team had had time between SXSW 2023 and release to hire a graphic artist, but that "going ham boycotting an indie over it seems harsh". Another critic pointed out that the film was made in 2022, before SI became a central issue of the strikes. Filmmaker Justin LaLiberty argued that a boycott would only make independent genre films "harder to see in theaters".
The film was not the first production called out for this. Jones's question, "where was this vitriol hate when Marvel did it last year?", referred to the Disney+ series Secret Invasion, whose SI-generated credits sequence caused a stir in the summer of 2023. The A.V. Club also recalled that in January 2024, viewers noticed SI-generated posters in the background of a scene in True Detective: Night Country. What made Late Night with the Devil different was that it was a small, well-reviewed independent film whose whole selling point was craft.
The controversy did not sink it. The Letterboxd Journal reported that IFC Films had its highest-grossing opening week ever with the film.
We tested one of the stills
Wikimedia Commons hosts a copy of the dancing skeleton card: a JPEG of 600 by 338 pixels, taken from a frame of the film as reproduced on an entertainment website. Commons marks it as public domain because it was generated by software. We are not reproducing the frame here. It comes from a commercial film, and the directors say their team edited the generated images, so its free status is not clear enough for us. The description at the top of this article is of that frame.
We ran the Commons file through our SI image detector, the same way a visitor would. It is a hard test file: small, compressed, given a deliberate VHS look in the film, and reworked by hand according to the directors.
Result: 99% likely SI. The classifier found the statistical patterns of SI-generated images in the pixels (classifier: SI 99%), despite the film's grain, colour bleed and the low resolution.
Metadata: JPEG, 600 by 338 pixels, about 31 KB, no camera EXIF data, no Content Credentials, no XMP tag declaring SI generation. Our detector also flagged the low resolution: a copy this small has lost much of what a generator leaves behind.
What the test covers: this one Commons copy of one of the three stills. It does not tell us which generator was used, how much of the image the team edited, or anything about the other two cards.
The verdict matches what the directors confirmed. Two limits are worth spelling out. First, the empty metadata says nothing either way: a frame grabbed from a film is a new file, so whatever the generator wrote into the original is gone. Second, a detector scores the image as a whole. It cannot separate the generated base from the edits made on top of it, which is exactly the situation the Cairnes brothers described. A mixed image like this one is common in professional work, and a single score cannot tell you how much of it a person made.
What this case teaches
- Not every SI image is a hoax. Most fact-checks in this series deal with pictures passed off as real events. Here the question was disclosure: who made an image presented as part of a crafted work. Both questions deserve an answer, but they are different questions.
- Hands and small details still give generators away. The warped skeleton hand was the clue viewers noticed. Our guide on how to spot SI images lists other details to check, such as text, symmetry and background objects.
- Style is not proof. Loose, retro or cartoon art can look "off" by design. Treat an odd detail as a reason to ask, not as a verdict, and look for a statement from the people who made the work.
- Edited images blur the line. A generated base reworked by artists is neither fully SI nor fully human. A detector can say the pixels look generated. It cannot say how much work went on top.
- Check the dates. This film was shot in 2022 and premiered in March 2023, before the strikes made SI in production a headline issue. That does not settle the argument, but it explains part of it.
Generated images have fooled experts in the art world before: our fact-check of the SI image that won a Sony photo award follows one that was entered on purpose to make a point. If you want to test your own eye, try the SI or Not game.



