Fact-checks

Putin kneeling before Xi: the SI image of March 2023

An empty cream armchair with a wooden frame stands on a dark red carpet under an amber glow; beside it, an oversized polished shoe breaks up at the toe into amber pixels that drift away to the right
Illustration created with Claude (Anthropic).

A picture of Vladimir Putin kneeling to kiss Xi Jinping's hand went viral during Xi's 2023 visit to Moscow. It was SI-generated. Here is how fact-checkers took it apart and what our detector returns on a copy.

Vladimir Putin is down on one knee on a red carpet, head bowed, kissing the hand of Xi Jinping, who leans over him. A man in a dark suit watches from the left, hands clasped. Cream chairs line the wall. The picture went around the world on 20 March 2023, the day the Chinese president arrived in Moscow, as if a photographer had caught a moment of submission behind closed doors.

It never happened. The image of Putin kneeling before Xi is an AI image, or in our words an SI-generated one: no camera was in that room, because the room does not exist. Fact-checkers in Germany, Italy and Taiwan, at Euronews and at Radio Free Asia took it apart within days. This article sums up what the fact-checks found, why the fake was so easy to believe, and what our is this SI tool returns on a copy of the picture taken from the earliest post fact-checkers could find.

Claim: a photo shows Vladimir Putin kneeling and kissing Xi Jinping's hand during Xi's state visit to Russia in March 2023.
Verdict: false. The two leaders did meet in the Kremlin on 20 March 2023, but no agency or official photo shows any kneeling. DW rated the claim false, CORRECTIV rated the image manipulated, and Open, Euronews, the Taiwan FactCheck Center and Radio Free Asia's Asia Fact Check Lab all concluded it was a fake, most likely made with an SI image generator. Our detector scored a copy 82% likely SI.

What really happened on 20 March 2023?

The meeting itself was real, and well documented. The Kremlin's own record, dated 20 March 2023, describes Putin meeting Xi Jinping, "who arrived in Russia on a state visit". In the published remarks, Putin welcomes his "dear friend" and congratulates him on his re-election as China's president. Formal Russian-Chinese talks and press statements followed on 21 March, according to the same Kremlin website.

The visit came at a tense moment. DW recalls that the International Criminal Court had just issued an arrest warrant for Putin, and that Western governments were pressing China to keep its distance from Russia. Radio Free Asia's Asia Fact Check Lab describes the first meeting as lasting four and a half hours. Agency and official photographers covered every stage of the visit, and none of their pictures showed a kneeling Putin, as the Taiwan FactCheck Center noted: the picture "did not appear in any news media or official Chinese or Russian footage" (our translation).

How did the image spread?

The earliest post that CORRECTIV could find was published on 20 March on a Ukrainian Telegram channel, NEWS.GRP, which describes itself as Ukraine's fastest news aggregator. A few minutes later, another Ukrainian Telegram channel shared the same picture, and that post was seen more than 300,000 times, according to CORRECTIV. The German fact-checkers add that follow-up posts made clear the picture had been meant as a joke.

It did not stay a joke. On Twitter, a correspondent for the Kyiv Post shared it with the caption "Putin attempting to persuade Xi". Fact Crescendo counted more than 780,000 views on that post alone, and DW estimated that, across platforms, the image had been viewed over a million times. It also travelled on imgur, LinkedIn and Facebook. Some users wrote that Putin was "swearing obedience and loyalty to his master and commander", a post quoted by DW. In Italy, Open found Facebook posts calling Putin a "devoted vassal" of the Chinese "emperor". In Taiwan, the Taiwan FactCheck Center saw it shared next to a cartoon of Putin kneeling before Winnie the Pooh.

The numbers differ from one fact-check to the next because each counted different posts on different days. What they agree on is the speed: in a single day, a picture with no author and no source was seen by hundreds of thousands of people.

How fact-checkers proved it was fake

Each team worked on its own, and they arrived at the same answer by three different routes: the origin of the file, the scene, and the pixels.

No photographer, no agency

A real photo of two heads of state usually has a credit: a pool photographer, Reuters, AP, TASS, Xinhua or the Kremlin press office. This one had none. DW searched the archives of Getty Images and of the Russian state agency TASS and found no trace of the scene. Euronews' verification team, The Cube, ran reverse image searches and found the picture only on social media: "No other mainstream news outlet published it." Open, the Italian fact-checking site, could not identify any author either.

CORRECTIV ran searches on Google, TinEye and Yandex, filtered to 20 March, and found only reposts. David Fischinger, a research engineer at the Austrian Institute of Technology interviewed by CORRECTIV, explained why that matters: when an SI image is generated from scratch, there is generally no single original photo to find. A reverse search that only returns copies of copies, all from the same day, is a clue in itself. Our guide on how to reverse image search shows how to run that check yourself.

The wrong room

The setting gave the fake away even before anyone zoomed in. The Asia Fact Check Lab compared it with AP and Kremlin pool photos of the meeting. The real room had pale green walls, white columns and white and beige chairs. The viral picture shows a red carpet, chairs with brown wooden frames and sage green walls. CORRECTIV made the same point: the carpet in the real photos is beige, not red, and the real chairs have white frames. Fact Crescendo noticed that Xi wore a black suit that day, while the picture dresses him in navy.

Hands, ears and one giant shoe

Then came the details that SI generators of early 2023 often got wrong. DW listed most of them:

  • the rear shoe of the kneeling man is far too large and wide, and the calf above it looks stretched;
  • his head, half hidden, is too big for his body;
  • his ear is deformed, with lumps that real photos of Putin's ear do not show, and Xi's ear also looks wrong when you zoom in;
  • the man standing on the left seems to have his hands fused together.

The other fact-checks added their own finds. Open compared the shoe to a Salvador Dalí painting and noticed that neither man wore the shoes seen in the real photos. CORRECTIV spotted a column in the background that runs crooked. The Asia Fact Check Lab saw a man on the far right whose legs fade out before the floor, furniture with missing or extra legs, and no trace of the watch Putin wore on his wrist in AP photos that day. Euronews pointed at Putin's blurry hand, "usually a good indication that an image has been generated by AI".

No single one of these flaws proves anything. A shoe can look odd in a real photo shot with a wide lens. Together, and combined with the wrong room and the missing credit, they leave no room for doubt.

A clue we do not rely on

The Asia Fact Check Lab also argued that the picture was online before the meeting it claimed to show, based on the time stamped on a repost. Times shown on screenshots of social media depend on the time zone of the person who took them, and the fact-check does not say which zone applied. We leave that argument aside: the case is solid without it.

What did SI detectors say in 2023?

This is where the story gets interesting for anyone who uses a detector. Several fact-checkers tried the free tools available at the time, and none of them gave a clear answer.

DW ran the picture through a detector hosted on Hugging Face, which estimated it was 57% artificially generated. CORRECTIV used an SI image detector hosted on Hugging Face and got 55%, a result it called not conclusive. To show why, CORRECTIV also tested a real photo of the American TV host Bill Maher from a picture agency: it scored 52%, almost the same. Euronews relayed a journalist's test with a Hugging Face detector that called the image artificial. The Taiwan FactCheck Center also mentioned a positive result, but warned that detectors were not precise and could only be a reference. Chen Jun-cheng, a researcher specialising in SI at Academia Sinica quoted by the Center, made the same point about current detection tools.

In other words, the fact-checks that held up were not built on a score. They were built on sources, on comparisons with real photos, and on visual details. The detector results were a side note. That is still the right order today, as our article on how accurate SI detectors are explains.

We tested a copy in our SI detector

No original file has been found, and fact-checkers only had reposts. The cleanest copy we could trace is the one in CORRECTIV's fact-check: a screenshot of the earliest Telegram post it found, on the NEWS.GRP channel. We cropped that screenshot to keep only the picture, without the channel name, caption or counters, and saved it as a PNG of 906 by 904 pixels. It is a copy of a copy: Telegram compressed it, CORRECTIV captured it as a screenshot, and we cropped it. Because this copy is a press screenshot with no free licence, we describe the picture here rather than reproduce it.

We then ran it once through our SI image detector, exactly as a visitor would.

Result: 82% likely SI. The classifier found the statistical patterns of SI-generated images in the pixels (classifier: SI 82%).

Metadata: PNG, 906 by 904 pixels, about 435 KB. No camera make or model and no EXIF date, a weak hint on its own. No Content Credentials and no XMP tag declaring SI generation.

What the test covers: this one cropped copy of the Telegram post, as published in CORRECTIV's screenshot. It does not say which generator made the picture, and it cannot recover anything about the original file.

The verdict agrees with the fact-checks, and it is clearer than the 55% and 57% of the 2023 tools. It is also less emphatic than the 99% we saw on files closer to their source, such as the castle picture in our fact-check of the flooded Disney World images. That fits what we know about copies: every round of compression, every screenshot and every crop wipes out part of the signal a classifier reads. The empty metadata proves nothing either way, since Telegram and screenshots strip it from real photos too.

Why this fake worked

The picture arrived at the perfect moment. The world was watching the meeting, and the pictures released officially showed two men on equal footing. A kneeling Putin offered a story that many people wanted to see: an isolated Russia begging China for help. It fitted a political reading of the visit, so it felt like a leak rather than an invention.

It also arrived in the same week as two other famous SI fakes. Pictures of Donald Trump being arrested, made with Midjourney, were spreading the same week, as told in our fact-check of the Trump arrest images. A few days later, the Pope in a white puffer jacket fooled a great many people, which we cover in our fact-check of the Pope puffer jacket image. March 2023 was one of the first moments when photorealistic SI images reached the general public, and when many people learned the hard way that a "photo" of a world leader could be typed into existence.

Finally, the picture was shared by people with authority. When a correspondent for a known newspaper posts an image with a dry caption, readers take it as reported fact. The joke, which CORRECTIV saw in the Telegram follow-ups, did not travel with the picture.

What this case teaches

  1. Ask who took the photo. Pictures of heads of state come from agencies and official photographers. No credit, no agency, no source: be careful.
  2. Compare with the official pictures. Summits are photographed from every angle. The carpet, the chairs, the walls and the clothes are easy to check against the real ones.
  3. Look at hands, ears and feet. The extremities are where SI generators of 2023 failed most often, and they remain worth a close look.
  4. Read detector scores as one clue. In 2023, free tools gave 55% to 57%, close to the score of a real photo. Our own tool gave 82% on a degraded copy. Neither replaces the checks above.
  5. Be wary of the picture you hoped to see. The more a photo confirms what you already believe about a political event, the more it deserves a second look.

Our guide on how to spot SI images walks through these visual checks step by step, and the SI or Not game lets you test your eye on real and generated pictures.

FAQ

Did Putin kneel before Xi Jinping?

No. Putin and Xi Jinping met in the Kremlin on 20 March 2023 during Xi's state visit to Russia, but no agency or official photo shows Putin kneeling or kissing Xi's hand. DW rated the claim false and CORRECTIV rated the image manipulated.

Is the Putin kneeling to Xi picture AI-generated?

Fact-checkers concluded it was most likely made with an AI (SI) image generator. They found no photographer or agency behind it, a room that does not match the real meeting, and typical generator errors: a giant deformed shoe, fused hands, misshapen ears and a head too big for the body. Our SI detector scored a copy 82% likely SI.

Where did the image of Putin kissing Xi's hand come from?

The earliest post CORRECTIV found was on a Ukrainian Telegram channel, NEWS.GRP, on 20 March 2023. Another Ukrainian channel shared it minutes later, and CORRECTIV found follow-up posts that treated it as a joke. It then spread on Twitter, imgur, LinkedIn and Facebook, including through a post by a Kyiv Post correspondent.

How can you tell the Putin and Xi image is fake?

Compare it with the official photos of the visit: the real room had pale green walls, white columns and white and beige chairs, while the fake shows a red carpet and brown wooden chairs. Then look at the details: Putin's rear shoe is far too large, the man on the left seems to have fused hands, and the ears are deformed.

Did AI detectors catch the Putin kneeling image in 2023?

Not clearly. DW got 57% from a detector hosted on Hugging Face and CORRECTIV got 55%, which it called inconclusive, while a real photo scored 52% in the same kind of test. The fact-checks relied on sources and visual comparisons rather than on detector scores.

Sources

  1. Fact check: No, Putin did not kneel before Xi Jinping · DW, 23 March 2023
  2. Wladimir Putin kniend vor Xi Jinping? Woran sich erkennen lässt, dass dieses Bild nicht echt ist · CORRECTIV, 29 March 2023
  3. Asia Fact Check Lab: Did Putin kneel before Xi Jinping? · Radio Free Asia, Asia Fact Check Lab, 25 March 2023
  4. La foto di Putin in ginocchio davanti a Xi Jinping è opera dell'intelligenza artificiale · Open, 21 March 2023
  5. Debunk: Did Putin kiss Xi Jinping's hand and did he send a body double to Mariupol? · Euronews, 23 March 2023
  6. 破解普亭下跪習近平的AI生成假照 (Debunking the AI-generated fake photo of Putin kneeling to Xi Jinping) · Taiwan FactCheck Center, 22 March 2023
  7. Fake Photo: Putin Did NOT Kneel Before Xi Jinping · Fact Crescendo, 30 March 2023
  8. Meeting with President of People's Republic of China Xi Jinping · President of Russia (Kremlin), 20 March 2023

Spotted an error? Write to hello@siornot.com. Corrections are made in the article and the update date changes. Read our editorial policy.