Fact-checks

Katy Perry at the Met Gala: the SI images that fooled her own mother

An empty cream ball gown on a dress form, decorated with orange and cream flowers, standing on a wide staircase between dark hedges; the right side of the skirt breaks up into amber pixels that drift away
Illustration created with Claude (Anthropic).

Two SI-generated images showed Katy Perry at the 2024 Met Gala. She was not there, and even her mother was fooled. Here is what was posted, how it was debunked, and what our detector returns.

A woman with long black hair stands at the foot of a staircase in a huge cream ball gown. The skirt is covered in three-dimensional flowers and butterflies and spreads over a mound of moss. Behind her, a wall of photographers holds up cameras under a draped white tent. In a second picture, the same woman wears a bronze corset shaped like an old key above a skirt of hanging vines and pale roses, in front of a garden wall.

Both pictures went around the world on the night of the 2024 Met Gala, on Monday 6 May 2024, as photos of Katy Perry. One Facebook post that shared them said she "ATE and left NO crumbs". The singer was not there. The images were made with SI (AI), and they fooled many people, her own mother included. This fact-check goes through what was posted, how fact-checkers and Perry herself set the record straight, which clues worked and which did not, and what our SI detection returns on a copy of one of the images.

Claim: photos show Katy Perry at the 2024 Met Gala, in a flower-covered gown and in a key-shaped corset.
Verdict: false. Perry did not attend the 2024 gala. She reposted the two images on Instagram the same night with the caption "Couldn't make it to the MET, had to work". PolitiFact rated the claim Pants on Fire on 7 May 2024, and Check Your Fact rated it False the next day. A copy of the corset image scored 99% likely SI in our detector.

What was posted, and where

The Met Gala is the yearly fundraiser for the Costume Institute of the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York. In 2024, the dress code was "The Garden of Time", taken from a short story by J.G. Ballard, and the co-chairs were Zendaya, Jennifer Lopez, Bad Bunny and Chris Hemsworth, according to The Hollywood Reporter.

According to the Associated Press, at least two SI-generated images of Perry began circulating on Monday night and early Tuesday, alongside fakes of other stars. PolitiFact traced one Facebook post from 6 May that shared both. Its caption read "Katy Perry ATE and left NO crumbs", followed by a heart-eye emoji, and the user filed the pictures in an album titled "2024 MET GALA". The screenshot PolitiFact published shows a little over 500 shares. Meta flagged the post as part of its fact-checking program.

On X, Check Your Fact found a post claiming the gown picture showed Perry: "Katy Perry looks absolutely gorgeous. Only her fans are allowed to like this tweet". The AP reported that X's Community Notes soon added context saying the images were likely created with SI. Perry was not the only target. The AP described a fake image of Rihanna in a white gown embroidered with flowers, birds and branches. Rihanna had been a confirmed guest but did not attend; People magazine reported that she had the flu. Creative Bloq noted similar fake outfits for Selena Gomez.

CBC News added that a TikTok influencer had given a glowing review of an outfit Kim Kardashian never wore, in a video with 9.6 million views. Kardashian was at the gala, but in a different look. Not every rumour that night was SI, either: a photo said to show Jason Derulo falling down the stairs was, according to the fact-checking site VerifyThis quoted by CBC, a real photo of someone else taken at the Cannes Film Festival in 2011.

How Perry and her mother ended up in the story

Hours after the images spread, Perry reposted both of them on her own Instagram account. The caption was a joke that doubled as a denial: "Couldn't make it to the MET, had to work". The AP said the post also included a muted video of her singing. Her representatives did not answer the AP's questions about why she was absent.

The same post carried a screenshot of a text exchange with her mother. As transcribed by PolitiFact, her mother wrote: "Didn't know you went to the Met. What a gorgeous gown, you look like the Rose Parade, you are your own float lol". Perry replied with a warning that ended in capital letters: "lol mom the AI got you too, BEWARE!" The AP and CBC quote the reply as "the AI got to you too"; the meaning is the same.

Cayce Myers, a professor at Virginia Tech's School of Communication, told the AP: "It used to be that seeing is believing, and now seeing is not believing", adding that if "even a mother can be fooled into thinking that the image is real, that shows you the level of sophistication that this technology now has." By the Wednesday morning, CBC reported, Perry's own Instagram post carried a warning from PolitiFact that the photo was SI-generated.

Nobody has publicly claimed the images. The AP wrote that their source or sources were hard to lock down, and that the realistic Met Gala backdrop in many of them suggested the tool used had been trained on images of past events. Getty Images, the gala's official photographer, declined to comment.

What the fact-checkers found

PolitiFact, writing on 7 May 2024, started with the simplest test: was she there? She was not, and she had said so herself. Perry had last attended the gala in 2022. PolitiFact then pointed to two visual clues in the gown picture.

  • The carpet. The real 2024 stairs were covered in a cream carpet with mossy green accents along the sides, lined with greenery-covered barriers, as The Hollywood Reporter described on the night. The fake has red patterns along the edges of the steps. The AP said this carpet matched the one from 2018. PolitiFact was more careful: it found it "much closer" to the 2018 carpet, with its red pattern on the edges and leaf-covered walls, but not identical.
  • The photographers. Looking closely at the press pack behind the gown, PolitiFact saw what it called inconsistencies common in SI-generated images: odd-looking hands and distorted faces.

Check Your Fact, on 8 May 2024, used a different route. A reverse image search led back to Perry's own Instagram post, with the caption saying she had not made it. It also ran the image through Hive Moderation, an SI detector, which found the image likely contained SI-generated content. Its verdict was False.

The 2018 resemblance fits what the AP suspected. That year's gala, for the exhibition Heavenly Bodies: Fashion and the Catholic Imagination, also had a cream carpet, with cathedral-like details. A tool trained on pictures of past galas can only reproduce past carpets; the 2024 one was unveiled on the night.

The clue that only worked once

The carpet argument is the one most people remember, and it is a good one for the gown picture. It is worth being honest about its limit, though. Look at the second image, the key corset: the steps behind Perry are pale cream with soft green edges, which is close to what the real 2024 carpet looked like. On that picture, the carpet clue does not help at all.

The corset picture has other oddities if you look for them. The key on the corset is a plausible object, but at the bottom left of the frame, near her hand, the skirt dissolves into a blue-grey shape that does not read as fabric, a bag or anything else. Her face and hair, the parts everyone looks at, show nothing wrong.

So the lesson is not "check the carpet". It is to check facts that do not depend on what the image chooses to show you. Was the person on the official guest lists and in the agency galleries from the night? Has the person or their team said anything? Does the photo appear anywhere before the viral post, and who posted it first? Those questions would have sorted out both images, whatever the stairs looked like. Our guide to running a reverse image search shows how to do the last one in a minute.

We tested a copy of the corset image

We could not find an original file of either image. We could not retrieve the files from Perry's Instagram post, and the video the X post cited by Check Your Fact linked to no longer loads. Most fact-checks show the pictures with crosses, arrows and labels drawn on top, which would distort a test. We used the cleanest copy we found: the corset image as published by Creative Bloq on 15 May 2024, credited to an X account. The publisher had placed it on a blurred 16:9 background, so we cropped that padding off before the test, leaving 1,070 by 1,080 pixels of the picture itself. We are not reproducing it here: it is a copy from a press article, not a file with a clear free status.

We then ran it through our SI image detector, exactly as a visitor would.

Result: 99% likely SI. The classifier found the statistical patterns of SI-generated images in the pixels (classifier: SI 99%).

Metadata: JPEG, 1,070 by 1,080 pixels, about 400 KB. No camera make or model, no Content Credentials, no XMP tag declaring SI generation. The EXIF data names Adobe Photoshop 25.4 with a date of 15 May 2024, the day the article was published: that is the publisher's editing, not the origin of the picture.

What the test covers: this one copy of the corset image, re-encoded on its way from social media to a news site. It does not tell us which generator was used, who made it, or anything about the gown image, which we did not test.

The verdict matches what Perry and the fact-checkers said. The metadata is a useful reminder of how little a file can tell you once it has travelled. The only software name in the file is the editing tool of a magazine, added nine days after the gala. Whatever the generator may have written into the original was stripped long before. That is normal: social networks and publishers rewrite image files, which is why provenance labels such as C2PA Content Credentials only help when they survive the trip, and why an empty metadata block proves nothing either way.

Why a harmless fake still matters

Compared with most images in our fact-check series, this one did little damage. Nobody lost money. CBC opened its piece with real looks from past galas, such as Jared Leto carrying his own head as an accessory.

The experts quoted at the time saw it as a rehearsal. The AP noted that sexually explicit fakes of Taylor Swift had circulated earlier that year, and quoted David Broniatowski of George Washington University: "The implications here go far beyond the safety of the individual". CBC quoted users on X who called the Met Gala fakes "a low-stakes prelude" to the 2024 election campaign. The AP also recalled that Getty Images had sued Stability AI, alleging that the company copied more than 12 million of its photographs without permission, a reminder that the realistic red-carpet look of such images comes from real photographers' work.

It also fits a pattern we have seen before. Our fact-check of the pope in a puffer jacket covered another fashion fake that people shared because it was fun, not because they had checked it. And the Trump arrest images showed how quickly a picture leaves its original context, labels included.

What this case teaches

  1. Check the event, not just the image. Official guest lists, agency galleries and the person's own accounts settle most celebrity fakes faster than any visual clue.
  2. Background people are a weak spot. Generators polish the main subject. Crowds, hands and faces in the back are where errors survive, as PolitiFact found with the photographers.
  3. A single clue can fail. The 2018-style carpet exposed the gown picture, but the corset picture had believable stairs. Use several checks, not one.
  4. Metadata on a shared copy describes the copy. Here it named a magazine's editing software. Read it as a trail of who handled the file, not as proof of where it came from.
  5. Your family is part of the audience. Perry's warning to her mother was a joke, but it is good advice for anyone who forwards a striking photo without checking it.

For a step-by-step method, our guide on how to spot SI images lists what to look at, from hands to text and lighting. If you want to train your eye on real and generated pictures side by side, try the SI or Not game.

FAQ

Was Katy Perry at the 2024 Met Gala?

No. Katy Perry did not attend the Met Gala on 6 May 2024. The photos of her in a flower-covered gown and in a key-shaped corset were SI-generated. She reposted them on Instagram the same night with the caption "Couldn't make it to the MET, had to work".

Are the Katy Perry Met Gala photos AI?

Yes. PolitiFact rated the claim that the images showed Perry at the 2024 Met Gala Pants on Fire, and Check Your Fact rated it False after a reverse image search and an AI detector check. A copy of the corset image scored 99% likely SI in our detector.

How did people spot that the Katy Perry Met Gala image was fake?

In the gown image, the carpet did not match the real 2024 carpet, which was cream with mossy green accents, and looked closer to the 2018 one. The photographers in the background had odd-looking hands and distorted faces. The simplest proof was Perry's own post saying she was not there.

Was Katy Perry's mom fooled by the AI image?

Yes. Perry shared a text in which her mother said she did not know Perry went to the Met and called the gown gorgeous. Perry replied that the AI had got her too and told her to beware.

Who made the AI images of Katy Perry at the Met Gala?

Nobody has claimed them. The Associated Press reported that the source or sources of the images were hard to lock down, and that the realistic backdrop suggested a tool trained on images of past galas.

Sources

  1. AI-generated images of Katy Perry at 2024 Met Gala fool social media users, Perry's mother · PolitiFact, 7 May 2024
  2. FACT CHECK: Image Claims To Show Katy Perry At The Met Gala · Check Your Fact, 8 May 2024
  3. Katy Perry and Rihanna didn't attend the Met Gala. But AI-generated images still fooled fans · Associated Press (via Spectrum News NY1), 7 May 2024
  4. Fake photos, but make it fashion. Why the Met Gala pics are just the beginning of AI deception · CBC News, 8 May 2024
  5. The 2024 Met Gala's Carpet Color and Design Scheme Explained · The Hollywood Reporter (via Yahoo News), 6 May 2024
  6. Everyone and their mother fell for those AI Katy Perry pics · Creative Bloq, 15 May 2024

Spotted an error? Write to hello@siornot.com. Corrections are made in the article and the update date changes. Read our editorial policy.